Healthcare Is a Business. So What Happens When Profit Gets Involved?

Let's talk about money.
Not your copay.
Not your deductible.
Not whether your insurance covered the MRI.
I'm talking about the much, much bigger question:
How much money is flowing through healthcare—and what happens when healthcare becomes a business?
Now, before anybody gets out their pitchforks, let's establish something.
I own a business.
I understand that businesses need to make money.
You have employees to pay. You have buildings to maintain. You have equipment to buy. You have technology. You have insurance. You have supplies. You have taxes. You have an electric bill that somehow costs approximately seventeen times what you think it should.
Making money isn't inherently bad.
In fact, making enough money to keep your doors open is pretty important.
Healthcare is no different.
Hospitals can't operate without revenue. Doctors can't practice without getting paid. Pharmaceutical companies can't develop new medications for free. Medical device companies don't manufacture complicated equipment out of the goodness of their hearts.
Healthcare costs money.
A ridiculous amount of money.
And that, by itself, isn't the problem.
The interesting part starts when we ask:
What happens when making money becomes one of the primary goals?
Because healthcare isn't quite like selling widgets.
If I buy a widget and it sucks, I can return it.
If the company doesn't deliver what it promised, I'm annoyed.
If the widget breaks, I buy another one.
Healthcare is different.
You don't generally go looking for healthcare because you're excited to make a purchase.
You go because something matters.
Your health.
Your ability to work.
Your ability to breathe.
Your parent.
Your child.
Your future.
You're making decisions while you're vulnerable, scared, sick, worried, or simply trying to understand what the hell is happening.
And that makes the financial side of healthcare…complicated.
Follow the money
Healthcare isn't one business.
It's an enormous ecosystem of businesses, organizations, government programs, nonprofit organizations, insurance companies, pharmaceutical companies, medical device manufacturers, hospitals, physician practices, pharmacies, laboratories, technology companies, and a whole lot more.
And they don't all make money in the same way.
Some are paid directly by people.
Some are reimbursed by insurance.
Some receive government funding.
Some make money by selling medications.
Some make money by selling equipment.
Some make money by licensing technology.
Some make money by providing services.
Some make money by managing other people's healthcare dollars.
And sometimes, several of these things are happening at the same time.
That's where incentives start getting interesting.
Because the way something gets paid can influence what gets offered, what gets emphasized, what gets invested in, and sometimes even what gets measured.
That doesn't automatically mean somebody is doing something unethical.
It means incentives matter.
We see this in virtually every industry.
But healthcare has a particularly interesting problem:
The person receiving the service isn't always the person paying for it.
You might receive a $5,000 procedure.
Your insurance company might negotiate a different amount.
The hospital has costs associated with providing it.
The physician may be paid separately.
The manufacturer of the device used during the procedure may make money from it.
And you may be responsible for some portion of the bill.
There are a lot of financial relationships happening around one human being.
And most of us have absolutely no idea how any of it works.
Honestly?
That's a problem.
Not because everyone needs to become a healthcare economist.
But because money influences systems.
And if you don't understand that money is part of the system, it's easy to assume that every decision being made around you is based solely on one question:
What is medically best for me?
Sometimes it is.
Sometimes there are other considerations happening simultaneously.
And then there's innovation
This is where things get really interesting.
Healthcare desperately needs innovation.
We want better diagnostic tools.
Better treatments.
Better medications.
Better technology.
Faster testing.
Less invasive procedures.
More accessible care.
More effective treatments.
Bring on the innovation.
But innovation also attracts enormous amounts of money.
And money creates pressure.
Investors want returns.
Companies want growth.
Organizations want market share.
Entrepreneurs want their companies to succeed.
Again—none of those things are inherently evil.
But eventually we have to ask:
What happens when the financial incentive gets stronger than the original purpose?
Theranos is an extreme example of what that can look like.
The company promised to fundamentally change blood testing. It attracted enormous attention and enormous investment before its technology was able to deliver what was promised.
The lesson isn't simply “don't make money in healthcare.”
That would be a ridiculous conclusion.
The more interesting lesson is what happens when hope, innovation, money, reputation, and healthcare all collide—and the safeguards that are supposed to protect people fail.
That's a much bigger conversation.
Because Theranos wasn't just about one company.
It raises questions about what we're willing to believe when something sounds revolutionary.
Who is asking the hard questions?
Who is checking the evidence?
Who is responsible for saying, “Wait a minute. Does this actually work?”
And perhaps most importantly:
Who pays the price when it doesn't?
So…how much is enough?
Here's where I get stuck.
I don't think healthcare shouldn't make money.
I don't think pharmaceutical companies shouldn't make money.
I don't think hospitals shouldn't make money.
I don't think entrepreneurs shouldn't build healthcare companies and become successful.
Go make money.
Seriously. Get the bag.
Build something amazing.
Create jobs.
Solve problems.
Invent something that changes people's lives.
Make a damn fortune.
But I also don't think we should be so uncomfortable talking about the financial incentives in healthcare that we pretend they don't exist.
Because they do.
And I think we're allowed to ask uncomfortable questions about them.
When does financial sustainability become profit maximization?
When does efficiency become volume?
When does innovation become monetization?
When does a new service exist because people genuinely need it—and when does it exist because there's a profitable market for it?
And what happens when those two things aren't the same?
I don't have a perfectly packaged answer for this.
I'm not sure there is one.
Because here's the tension:
Healthcare has to be financially sustainable.
But healthcare also exists for a reason.
People.
I own a business. I need to make money to stay in business.
But I don't need enough money to buy a private island if nobody is healthy enough to come visit me on it.
And maybe that's where my discomfort comes from.
Not from the idea of profit.
From the idea that more profit can become the goal even when it starts pulling us away from the reason the system exists in the first place.
Maybe the question isn't:
“Should healthcare make money?”
Maybe the better question is:
How much is enough—and what are we willing to sacrifice when “more” becomes the goal?



Comments